Many people think the scariest part of MSCI removing Strategy is the $2.8 billion passive stock sell-off.
But I believe the real thing to be wary of this time is not this $2.8 billion at all.
It's that Saylor's most important money-making machine over the past few years—the flywheel of issuing stock, raising funds, and buying Bitcoin—is losing momentum.
On November 12, MSCI officially announced the index adjustment results, with Strategy (MSTR) listed for removal from the US index, effective after the close on November 30.
What was the market's first reaction?
Passive funds are going to sell the stock!
Strategy previously warned that if removed from the index, it could trigger about $2.8 billion in stock sell-offs. That number is indeed alarming, but many people miss a key point:
Funds selling MSTR stock does not mean money is being taken out of Strategy's company accounts, nor does it mean the company must sell Bitcoin.
This is secondary market stock trading, not directly withdrawing money from the company's balance sheet.
Moreover, Saylor does have cash on hand.
As of November 11, Strategy's official website disclosed about $4.768 billion in USD reserves. Based on the current annual dividend and interest expenses of about $1.461 billion, this reserve theoretically covers about 39 months.
So, a short-term debt crisis is not the most worrying aspect of this event.
The real problem is just beginning.
The issue lies with ATM financing.
What is ATM? Simply put, Strategy can continuously issue MSTR stock on the market, take investors' money, and use it to buy Bitcoin.
Why has this approach been so powerful over the past few years?
Because MSTR's stock price usually carries a premium over the net asset value of its Bitcoin holdings.
Assuming the company holds $100 worth of Bitcoin, and the market is willing to value it at $120 in stock, it can use this $20 premium to raise funds and continue buying BTC.
The higher the premium, the easier the financing; the easier the financing, the more BTC it can buy; the more BTC it holds, the higher the market valuation it can command.
This is Saylor's flywheel.
But now, this flywheel is starting to stall.
Look at the latest data.
As of November 11, Strategy's official website shows MSTR's mNAV has dropped to about 1.08 times.
This means the market valuation premium has shrunk to a very thin layer.
More notably, from November 2 to 8, Strategy raised $283.8 million through issuing common stock.
Where did this money go?
- $188.3 million was used to repurchase STRC preferred stock, accounting for 66.3%.
- $81.9 million was used to purchase 1,036 BTC, accounting for 28.9%.
- The remaining $13.6 million went into the USD cash account.
Do you see?
Previously, the bulk of financing was for buying Bitcoin; now, two-thirds of the money is used to repurchase preferred stock.
This doesn't mean Strategy has stopped buying Bitcoin, but it indicates its funds are increasingly used to maintain capital structure rather than purely expanding Bitcoin holdings.
Looking at valuation again.
According to partial net asset value models, if MSTR's stock price further falls to around $115, it may reach the Bitcoin net asset parity region corresponding to common stock.
Once the premium disappears, continuing to issue common stock to buy BTC will hardly create the same value-added effect as before and may even dilute existing shareholders' equity.
This is the most dangerous part.
Moreover, MSTR has dropped about 20% year-to-date, while Bitcoin has fallen about 15% in the same period.
In other words, the market is not only lowering Bitcoin's valuation but also actively withdrawing the financing premium once granted to Strategy.
So, how do I view this MSCI removal event?
In the short term, it's the selling pressure possibly brought by passive funds.
In the medium term, it's the risk of further contraction of MSTR's valuation premium.
In the long term, it's whether Strategy's business model can continue to sustain itself.
There's also an easily overlooked detail: if other index providers follow suit, the impact could expand further. JPMorgan previously estimated that if other index providers take similar actions, Strategy's potential capital outflow could reach $8.8 billion.
MSCI removing Strategy doesn't directly snatch $2.8 billion from Saylor's pocket but dismantles the financing advantage he has relied on for years.
$4.77 billion in cash can help him weather the storm for a while.
But cash can solve payment issues, not necessarily valuation problems.
If MSTR's premium continues to disappear, even if Saylor still holds a large amount of Bitcoin, he may no longer be able to easily expand his position by issuing stock as before.
$BTC$MSTR$STRC
Disclaimer: OKX Orbit content is provided for informational purposes only. Learn more